🤓 Cody Plofker shares 3 frameworks from 3 DTC copywriters
😎 Connor Rolain gives four last-minute Black Friday checks
🤩 Mike Beckham reveals the agency behind his site’s rebuild
|
|
Connor Rolain
Head of Growth, HexClad
|
One Week to Black Friday: 4 Last-Min Checks
BFCM is the ultimate stress test for ecom brands, and the countdown is officially on.
You’ve already spent months preparing, but too often it’s small oversights that can turn into costly mistakes.
- Mobile site stalls at peak traffic
- Shipping questions pile up
- Creators share a rival’s discount
- First-time buyers get no follow-up
That’s why Levanta just released for an on-demand webinar that walks through four last-minute checks.
☐ Site: Is checkout costing you sales?
☐ Support: Can CX handle the rush?
☐ Creators: Will they prioritize you?
☐ Retention: Why would buyers return?
They reveal where to look and how to fix potential problems before Turkey Five. Plus, the Q5 strategies that keep paying off long after Cyber Monday ends.
Go through it today. Make sure you’re ready for Black Friday … and what comes after.
|
|
Cody Plofker
Advisor, Jones Road
|
Three Professional DTC Copywriters Tore Apart Our New Brand: Here’s What You Can Learn
Last month, I posted this on X:
Nobody is more AI-pilled than me. I built and shipped nine different landing page variants for Winks in the first week with no designer.
Claude wrote 90% of the copy.
And guess what?
It is not working very well.
Our acquisition targets and CPMs are still not where they need to be for us to get this brand off the ground.
Here’s what I know:
If we say the right words in the right order, people will buy.
Matt and I brought on three of the best DTC copywriters we could find. We handed them our product and our site, and gave each 30 minutes to tear it apart.
Here’s what they taught us.
1. “Copy is 95% research.”
When Matt asked who the top DTC copywriters are on X, Charles Burdett proclaimed himself the best.
He’s the founder of Pip Decks.
His decks run $99 to $149 each. On paper, his business shouldn’t work. He’s selling glorified B2B playing cards. If he pitched it on Shark Tank, they’d probably laugh at him.
He’s grown the company to £40m in revenue, without any investors. The secret?
Customers wrote most of his copy.
When Charles started, he spent six weeks on back-to-back calls with his earliest buyers. One described the product as “a cheat code for my job.”
That became a core message … and it still is today.
First off, talk to your customers. Second, when you ask them questions, swap “why” for “what made you.” It feels less pointed, and the answers get richer:
- “What made you actually buy?”
- “What gave you doubts at first?”
- “What made you almost not buy?”
Do not ask what they’d pay.
Charles calls it “the dumbest question in the whole entire planet.” When he asked, people said about a fifteenth of what his decks sell for today.
“Would you buy this?” is just as bad. Everyone says yes.
2. “Think in modifiers.”
Nicolas Cole was Quora’s most-read writer in 2015, built a multimillion-dollar ghostwriting agency, and co-founded Ship 30 for 30.
His framework starts with a simple question.
Can someone understand what you sell and what makes it different in a few words?
For example:
- Gluten-free bread
- Electric car
- Melatonin-free sleep aid
You can immediately understand in just 2-3 words what the product is and why it’s unique.
Nicolas calls this “thinking in modifiers.”
Plenty of top DTC brands do this. Eight Sleep sells a “temperature-controlled mattress.” Grüns sells “superfood greens gummies.”
Here’s how to find potential modifiers for your brand.
Identity
Put the buyer, and what they’re dealing with, in the name.
You can take any category and add one of these words, and now it’s built for a specific person.
Diabetic, beginner, prenatal, postpartum, menopausal, senior, sensitive-skin, plus-size, petite, vegan, keto, night-shift, new-parent, professional.
What’s New
A soda brand with nothing to own adds probiotics and becomes a “probiotic soda.”
Probiotic soda, protein cereal, collagen coffee, heated jacket, waterproof sneakers, self-cleaning water bottle, RFID-blocking wallet, weighted blanket.
What’s Left Out
Sometimes, what’s missing is what sells.
Melatonin-free sleep aid, alcohol-free spirits, fragrance-free lotion, gluten-free pasta, decaf cold brew, minimalist wallet, cordless vacuum, plastic-free phone case.
The Pain Point
Name the problem as plainly as you can.
Snore tape, acne patches, anti-chafe balm, blue-light glasses, hangover patches, blister bandages, dandruff shampoo, anti-fog goggles.
3. “We know you’re not an idiot.”
Nate Lagos has spent eight years running growth at DTC companies. Now he’s a mercenary for hire.
Most copy jumps from the problem straight to the product.
You can’t sleep. Here’s our sleep supplement.
Nate adds a step in between: acknowledge what the customer has already tried.
They haven’t been sitting around waiting for your brand to save them. They’ve attempted to fix this. Probably many times. Show them you understand that.
His framework is “but, then, therefore.”
Start …
With acute pain, not chronic pain. What is the pain your target market is experiencing right now?
“You’re exhausted, you work hard, you run around all day, you should be able to lay your head down at night and get good sleep.”
But …
Get specific here. Each ad could have a different BUT section to target a different audience / persona / use case / whatever.
“But, you can’t. Your mind races thinking about what you have to do tomorrow. You toss and turn. When you do sleep, it’s not restful. It’s shallow.”
Then …
This is a crucial section for building trust with your audience. Too many ads treat people like they’re dumb. This acknowledges that they’ve tried to fix this problem.
Your audience should feel seen. They should feel like you understand them. They should feel like they’re not at fault for trying to fix this with weak solutions. Most importantly, it should lead into a feeling of relief when you present the solution.
“Then, you turn to band aids: an extra glass of wine after dinner, maybe melatonin, and worst of all, a high dose of caffeine to get you through the next day, and your sleep problems only get worse.”
Therefore …
Fill this up with proof. The science behind the product and how it benefits them. Social proof. You already proved in the first half of the content that you understand the problem deeply. Now is the time to show off how well you understand the solution.
“So, we created this formula to attack the specific root causes of your sleep struggles.”
Should AI Write Your Copy?
I’m still going to use AI.
But I’m also going to apply and test what Charles, Nicolas, and Nate shared during these 90 minutes.
- Use your customer’s words
- Make the difference obvious
- Show empathy + a better way
That means talking to customers, getting meticulous about the language, and testing which messages make people buy.
It also means crafting some headlines with my own keyboard.
Once we find what works, AI can turn it into ads, emails, and landing pages. The next step is not just more words. It’s to figure out which words are worth scaling.
|
|
Mike Beckham
CEO, Simple Modern
|
Doing Over $8M Per Year? Get a Free Funnel Audit
When you want someone to improve the results for your DTC website, who do you call?
A few years ago, HexClad redesigned their website and increased revenue per visitor by 13%. Ridge did the same and improved their add-to-cart rate by 7%.
So when we wanted to overhaul Simple Modern’s site, we called the agency behind both of those builds: VAAN.
Xavier Armand’s team combined performance and branding beautifully, right down to our custom cart, with free-shipping thresholds, cross-sells, and upsells.
Now VAAN has joined forces with two more agencies.
Homestead runs acquisition, email, and SMS. Verndale handles platform, data, and experience design.
Most brands split their funnel between different vendors.
- Ads agency
- Site partner
- Email shop
Nobody owns how a customer moves from the ad to the product page, to checkout, to the inbox.
VAAN can do it all.
To mark the three teams coming together, VAAN opened up 50 free Full Funnel Audits for DTC brands doing +$8M. One audit covers creative, paid, site, checkout, and retention.
What you get:
- Scorecard for your funnel
- Where customers drop off
- Roadmap + plan for 2027
- One full hour with their team
They’ll run the audit in December or January. You’ll start the New Year with a clear to-do list.
It’s free, with no commitment.
Copy Is the Last Skill Standing. 3 Pros Take On Our Brand
With thanks and anticipation,
Aaron Orendorff
🤓 Chief Executive Officer
P.S. (Disclaimer): Special thanks to Levanta and VAAN for sponsoring today’s newsletter.